Quantcast

This Kind Of Life

I couldn’t sleep last night.

We’re making an offer on a second house (the one with lots of space that’s a bit of a blank slate, design-wise), and while I doubt the owners are going to come down enough to allow us to get it, they might…and I am definitely more than a little nervous. It is such a big deal. And I’m scared.

The fact is, of course, that this isn’t a decision that we’ve made quickly, or that we haven’t thought through: we’ve been circling the idea of moving to the Hudson Valley since last winter, and have spent the past year saving up and looking at places. And we are both certain that a move is what we want, both on an emotional level and a logical one: the truth is that we’re just not reaping any of the benefits of living in Manhattan these days, and city living is getting in the way of our life more than it’s enhancing it. Plus, since we’d have to move to someplace more child-friendly (with, say, a bedroom door, and maybe an elevator so I don’t feel so trapped) within a year, we’d be talking about rent prices that are at least equal to, if not more than, the kinds of mortgages we’re looking at. And finally, I’ve lived in the suburbs before – in LA – and the way of life was much more to my liking: on a Saturday, I’d rather have friends over to BBQ and hang out at home than do…well, anything. The things that we like to do best these days are just not the kinds of things that are worth paying to live in the city for.

Most of all, though, the reason we want to move is that city life is not what we want for our son. I grew up here, and I had a great childhood, but I want something different for him. I want him to have a yard to run around in with Lucy and Virgil. I want him to go fishing on Saturdays with his Dad not because it’s a big, special production involving car rentals and long drives, but rather because that’s just what they feel like doing. I want to pick up our pumpkin in a patch, not in a grocery store. I want him to have a swing set of his very own.

But it’s an enormous change for us, and I’d be lying if I said it wasn’t scary. I’m scared that I won’t make any friends, or that I won’t make friends that are the kinds of friends that I have in my life now (which is to say, real friends rather than friends of convenience). I’m scared that Kendrick and I will fight about stupid things like home repairs and mowing the lawn. I’m scared that we’ll move in and suddenly realize that we picked the wrong place, and that we would have been happier if we had moved just one town over, or to another state altogether. And you know something else I’m scared of? I’m scared that one day, a few years from now, my husband will wake up and look at me and at the life that we’ve built and think, Is that it? Is that all I get? I’m scared that he’ll think that. I’m scared that I’ll think that.

Because these towns, you know, they’re so quiet. They don’t have all those bright city lights to distract you from what’s right there in front of you. And what if, when all the lights go down, it’s not enough?

Kendrick has a friend who once said that New York City takes all the basic facets of normal human existence away from you, and then sells them back to you one at a time as luxuries. Want a bathroom that fits more than one person at a time? That’ll cost ya. A bedroom door? Five hundred extra per month. Don’t even ask about closets; you don’t get those unless you work on Wall Street.

And the thing about all this struggle – because living in the city is a struggle; it can be such a great ride, but it’s certainly not easy – is that it keeps you dreaming that things will change. One day, you say to yourself, I’ll move to Italy and have a yard full of lemon trees. Or maybe I’ll buy a place in California, right on the ocean. Or maybe I’ll find a gorgeous townhouse in the far reaches of Brooklyn. All you know is that where you are right then isn’t where you’ll likely stay, and there’s something very freeing in that knowledge. You don’t know where you’ll be, but you know it won’t be where you are.

Like many others I know of my generation, I was raised by parents who encouraged me to think that I had all the choices in the world, and all the time in the world to make them. We spent years being told that we could do anything, be anything – even our liberal arts curriculums let us play around in various fields for years before choosing a major, if we ever had to at all.

And that’s great. It is, it’s a wonderful thing – a privilege - to feel that you can do anything…but it also makes it really hard to finally choose what you want to do. Why should I marry this amazing guy when I’ve never even been to Asia yet? My even-more-perfect man might be waiting there for me. Why should I accept this pretty cool job offer when I haven’t even tested the waters in these five other career paths? I might like something else better. Why should I move to this one town, when there are so many other places in the world that might make the perfect home?

So I’ve found it very hard to make this leap. Because this enormous step – buying a house – is an incredible thing, an incredible opportunity…but it also shuts down so many other possibilities. We won’t be moving to Italy anytime soon. And of course we were never going to – of course we weren’t – but it was nice to think that maybe, just maybe, we might. We could. And if we make this decision…well, we can’t. Not for awhile, anyway.

But sometimes you need to just put on your Grownup Pants and decide, already. Weigh the pros and cons, figure out what’s important to you, argue with yourself to pieces…but then do it. Jump.

I have to say, though – I don’t know that I would have had the courage to make that jump a year ago. But now it’s not about us anymore, not really: it’s about a little man who smiles so much when he looks out our New York City window, even when there’s nothing to see outside but the apartment building across the way, that all we want to do is set him free to study the sky. And when we take that into account…

well…

it’s not really a decision at all.

It’s just what we’re going to do. 



You Might Also Like:


  • guest

    well done, well said 

  • Jennifer

    This was beautiful and really encapsulated everything that I’ve been feeling recently. My husband and I just moved from Washington DC to central Massachusetts for my job and it’s exciting and scary for the reasons you just laid out. I’m excited about the opportunity for our family to have this space and the Grown Up lifestyle that you describe, but hesitant about this entire change altogether. While we were still benefiting from the city and still want to, it had stopped being as enjoyable. Like you, I felt like it was impeding our growth and advancement with regard to the size of living space, transportation, and accessibility to different things. I know we made the right choice to jump, but there are times when I am afraid I will regret it… or we will become sick of one another… or become “those people” who talk about home improvement non stop… or whatever.

  • Ellen

    “And you know something else I’m scared of? I’m scared that one day, a few years from now, my husband will wake up and look at me and at the life that we’ve built and think, Is that it? Is that all I get? I’m scared that he’ll think that. I’m scared that I’ll think that.”

    Oh my goodness- I’m marrying the most wonderful man I’ve ever set eyes on in 2 months, and you’ve just summed up all my fears. And somehow eased them at the same time, by acknowledging I’m not alone.

    Thank you.

  • http://twitter.com/misathemeb The Delicate Place

    this happened to me in reverse order sans kid. i bought a house in the suburbs and it only took 2 years for me to figure out that it was not in my future. my husband and i had many heart to hearts and grew closer together but we moved to the city one year ago this month actually (back to renting!) and it’s the happiest i’ve ever been. i’m a scientist so most of my thought is logical, rational, sensible you know? but in terms of life’s happiness i always follow my heart. it sounds like you are as well and i wish you nothing but finding that happiness for your little family! x

  • JM

    I used to live in NYC. I lived there for 16 years of my life (I’m 33), and last September I moved to a small little village outside of Paris with my husband. To be honest, after we moved I realized I probably should have left NYC 5 years ago. I do miss my family and friends, and meeting new people is both a challenge and scary, but I’m learning not to think as much before I leap. This move has taught me that taking risks can change your life in exciting and adventurous ways. I have also learned how to enjoy the present more, instead of always obsessing about the future (which I did A LOT in NYC). 
    You’ll be FINE – and when you get nervous or anxious about leaving, take comfort in the fact that your friends and family are a short train ride away. I wish mine were :)

    One of my favorite quotes; I think you will like:

    “What is that feeling when you’re driving away from people and they recede on the plain till you see their specks dispersing? – it’s the too-huge world vaulting us, and it’s good-bye. But we lean forward to the next crazy venture beneath the skies.” – Jack Kerouac 

    Good luck with the offer on the house!

  • http://sartorialperfection.tumblr.com/ sarah

    jordan,
    i am a dedicated reader of your blog, though i rarely comment – but i just wanted to let you know that this post was beautiful. i’m a bit of a sap, but it brought tears to my eyes. never mind that the topic itself is a little bit gut-wrenching, because we’re all always afraid to jump – but in this post ( and in many others before) you have truly found your voice as a writer, and it is a beautiful thing. congratulations on all the steps you’re making, and thanks for sharing them with us. 

  • Beth

    “And you know something else I’m scared of? I’m scared that one day, a few years from now, my husband will wake up and look at me and at the life that we’ve built and think, Is that it? Is that all I get? I’m scared that he’ll think that. I’m scared that I’ll think that.”Thank you so much for sharing this with your readers Jordan.  I just bought a house with a wonderful man, but I’ve had these fears in the back of my mind lately as well.  Hearing that other people are having them as well makes me realize that I’m not alone, and that really there isn’t anything to worry about.  Life isn’t perfect, but there is no use stressing about what might happen.  That just ends up wasting the moments that are perfect right now. 

  • Emily

    I’ll echo Sarah – longtime reading, first time commenting. I’ve so enjoyed the window into your world over the past few years, reading about culinary triumphs, holiday adventure, trips, and most recently the birth of your son. I want to thank you for this thoughtful post, which so clearly resonates with me and many other readers. Whether it is comforting or creepy (or maybe a bit of both?) you’ve got a semi-anonymous cheering section spread across the country, rooting for you and excited for the new adventures that keep coming your way. I too have some “Grownup Pants” moments that I am on the cusp of embracing, and reading your reflections on these big life decisions gives me a sense of hope, purpose, and connection. Wishing you the very best (and keeping my fingers crossed for an accepting bid!).

  • valeire

    really loved this post, jordan!

  • Kiersten

    This post was a beautiful personal way for us faithful readers to peer into your life and we’re very thankful for you allowing us to see your fears and anxieties as well as your hopes and dreams. Making grownup decisions IS scary. It scares me to death. But always remember you are not alone and I think it will really help. You have a wonderful husband who loves you and supports you. I have a strong feeling that he will not resent you if you both move out of the city. I completely understand why you want a different environment for the baby. Children need to grow in the outdoors and go fishing with their dads and playing with mom and the dogs. Everything is going to be ok Jordan!

  • Abalkrishna

    Bravo, my dear. Very well stated.

  • Lauren B

    really wonderful post and reminded me of how great a writer you are. i think anyone living in the city can attest to your every word and how true it is that the future – whatever it might hold – is such a delightful mystery, but the reality of actually moving away is SCARY!

    thanks for being open & honest and best of luck to you guys with finding a house. i can’t imagine how stressful it must be, but i hope to know that feeling one day, too, with my own family :)

  • Michelle

    Lovely post! I think you mentioned before that you were looking at Ossining–my husband grew up there and I was raised in lower Westchester.  We also lived in the city for a spell–but we purchased a house in Northern Westchester 2 years ago and now have two kids.   It’s amazing–and there really are so many options for you to pursue. The area is gorgeous and as you are experiencing, the city is only a train ride away.  I’ve been reading your blog for a while, and I think you guys sound like you are ready for the change :) .  That said–it will be a change! We lament that good take out is pretty rare without having to drive 10/15 minutes, the shortage of ATM’s and 24 hr deli’s..but put into perspective, it’s all worth it.  Email me if you ever need tips or advice on area stuff. 

  • Anonymous

    I’m more mixed on the topic. I grew up very lovely suburbs with fantastic schools, and I really do not want to raise my children there. At the end of the day, it becomes all about consumption. No swing set, no house, no island kitchen table is ever big enough. Once you start living with space, you always want more. You can always have another car, another garage section, a bigger yard….it just never ends. Honestly, all the families did well, but I saw very little intellectual curiosity, and if anything, since the only thing to do is to go to the mall, you become obsessed with shopping at an early age. I’d rather pay money for a smaller place and have access to seven museums via a subway and get my kids into that at a early age.

    Also – property taxes in the suburbs, particularly NJ, are no joke. Because of state  budget cuts, municipalities increase property taxes on a regular basis. When you’re someone like my dad who lost their job in their 50s, it is no fun. You may have paid off your mortgage, but the majority of your money was actuall going to your property tax. Also, toll hikes on bridges, the hikes on the train fare…not cheap if you have to commute to the city for your job.

    The biggest concern with raising a kid in the city is honestly the schools – to have to move to different neighborhoods, join a synagogue or what not to get your kid into a decent elementary school is a huge, huge problem, and that really is the best part of the suburbs. Though I’m not hearing that in your post at all…you don’t have to join a lottery to go to a decent middle school.

  • http://www.losingweightinthecity.com/ Theodora

    I’m definitely nowhere near this stage of my life yet, but I am pretty sure this is exactly how I will feel. It sounds like you’re making the right decision for you and your family, though. The best decisions are usually the hardest ones to make.

  • Shivashakti81

    I have often thought exactly the same thing – that having SO MANY choices these days makes it diffifult to narrow down what you really want…40 years ago, my mother knew the only options available to her were to get married and raise a family. It’s not even that those options were available – that was all she was ever told she could have. I have so many more options in my life, but it’s terrifying sometimes.

    One thing I read or heard years ago that has always stuck with me…Not choosing is a choice too. It’s okay to be scared. You should be scared about making a major life change!! But if you didn’t make a choice, the years would pass and you would still be in the city and you would still long for a big house in the suburbs. By not making a choice, you end up with the default – things staying the way they are.

  • Alex

    Oh my god, you just verbalized every anxiety I have about the future and life decisions. Thank you.

  • http://twitter.com/egajones Ega Jones

    Jordan, holy moses. This is exactly what I feel about New York and growing up and all of it. Thank you for this. I still feel anxious and terrified and uncertain about the billions of choices out there, but I’m glad to know I’m not the only one.

  • http://wanderlustonpaper.wordpress.com/ Heather

    I’m right there with you. my husband is in the last few months of optometry school and has accepted a job in a small, quaint town on the farrr west coast of Canada. so we’ll be living there by the end of the summer. and while it excites me on so many levels to start that chapter of my life, it also paralyzes me with anxiety sometimes. 
    it’s a big deal, and this post was exactly what I needed to read today. :)

  • Anonymous

    Just so well written. Wow.

  • http://www.ONETHINGwithKyleCollins.com KyleCollins

    I love this. I was thinking this week – I’ve been doing the “adult” thing for a while now, but I still want to throw a tantrum sometimes when those “grownup pants” must come out. It’s all such a compromise, right?! Sigh.

    I interviewed an LPC a while back who said something that helped me get some peace about an aspect of what you talk about above.

    She said that our generation is the first to have SO MANY OPTIONS in front of us, in all areas of our lives. Which — yes! — makes us so fortunate but ALSO is, as she said, “crazy-making.”

    One step at a time. One day at a time. May grace lead us where it will, and may we allow ourselves to be led.

    Best of luck in this new journey!

  • Pingback: About Me | Ramshackle Glam by Jordan Reid

  • Regan

    As another that lives in northern Westchester, I second everything Michelle says. And, really, NYC will just be your little boy’s extended backyard. The Hudson Valley is just teeming with museums, working farms that kids can explore, and farmer’s markets. And the history! And the great Jack-o-Lantern Blaze! It may be laid back, but there are vibrant people here! And my two shih tzus love our area. That’s very important, too! And everytime I board the Metro North train to go back home, a little sigh escapes me when I see the quiet Hudson. Best of luck with the offer! (Pedicures are a bit more expensive. not much, but just a tad.)

  • http://twitter.com/ohthatlaura Laura

    This move will be a perfect turn on life’s journey. It’ll be filled with bumps, hiccups, laughter, frustration and lots of small joys. Years from now, you and Kendrick will both smile and fondly remember when you packed up the NYC apartment. I’m sure of it!!

  • http://blog.neverbroken.com alliebeau

    Welp. You just made me cry at my desk.
    I just had my five-year review at my job yesterday. I work for a very unstructured, successful startup company. 
    So, pretty much, the sky has always been the limit. When I walked in fresh out of college and immediately began to prove myself, they began to offer up every opportunity under our little roof to me.Except now, when I sit down with my CEO and he says, “what do you think you want to do after here?”
    I just…can’t answer.
    There’s too many possibilities. 
    And while this offers no resolution, it’s nice to know that someone in an utterly different situation feels the same way.
    <3 Get some sleep.
    PS, in the words of Ben Folds, you guys will rock the suburbs.

  • http://onelasttoday.tumblr.com/ Jennifer Faught

    I can COMPLETELY agree with  this.  All my childhood, growing up, I decided, i WILL live in a BIG city. I’ll be wildly independent and won’t need anyone to be by my side. When it came down to making those plans, my best friend moved to NYC and I made plans shortly after visiting. Then, as if something needed to keep me, the man of my dreams walked in. Here we are, thinking about where to buy houses, and I wonder to myself, I must need to be here for a reason. Afraid that this is not everything I dreamt of, but knowing, God’s making big changes in my life, for a reason.  This gift I call my husband, is the reason I don’t get lonely at night, he’s the best friend that’s ALWAYS there for me, and the only person I could ever be nervous about creating a future with… others from my past were great people, but didn’t make me nervous, didn’t give me butterflies, and didn’t keep me hoping they’d still love me in 10 years just the same. 

    Love this post.  

  • Nicoleella10

    Such a beautiful post and so well said. I think you articulated everything I was feeling prior to us buying our first home. Good luck!

  • Valeri

    Ditto. 100%. Literally started crying while I was reading this. Write a book Jordan, for real.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002861720182 Coffee Cashmere

    So well written!!

  • elledoc

    This was such a stunningly beautiful post. Thank you for this. I am a married woman living in Manhattan, feeling completely torn by my love for this amazing city and a desire to be anywhere else in the world…It’s such a bizarre dichotomy. There are days when I wake up and am so in love with NYC that I couldn’t imagine living anywhere else, and then there are days when I wake up feeling claustrophobic, wanting to live in a remote cabin somewhere where I can wake up to complete silence as the sun rises over a mountain or a lake.

    Anyway, as my husband and I look to start a family over the next few years we will be facing similar decisions. Thank you for sharing your hopes and dreams and fears, and I look forward to further following you adventure on this blog!

  • Kyle

    What a great post.  You’ve said everything I’ve been thinking but never even realized.  Perfectly articulated.  And your commenters as well, I can’t agree more.  A generation with just so much on the Possibility Plate that we sit stuck, frozen in indecision.   I guess what it boils down to is just choosing.  Choose to do something.  If it doesn’t work out, you choose to change it :)

  • jess

    I think buying a home or your first home comes with a lot of commitment phobia issues one never realized they had. It gave me heart palpation just signing on the dotted line. I thought what if I regret it? I’m stuck for a least a while….but its just a house its what I want “right now” not forever. My husband and kids are my forever in my mind. And that gave me comfort in knowing if and when we outgrow this home we will find our next home and so on. I had buyers remorse once when I bought a sports car. I literally drove back 3 days later and tried to give it back. It cracks me up now thinking back. Who does that? I drove that car for three more years and loved every second of those years. I traded it in only AFTER I gave birth to my twins. I probably looked hilarious rolling out of it preggers. Point is; you WILL have buyers remorse after a large purchase you’ll think its a money Pitt, and then one day after maybe 6 months or so you’ll be so happy with your decision! If its meant to be you’ll get the house. Good luck J I’m rooting for your new adventure in the suburbs.
    Jess

  • Anonymous

    As a longtime reader of yours, this post got me thinking: how does all of this come from the same girl who got engaged after a matter of weeks? I don’t mean that to sound critical in any way… your and Kendrick’s story is such a sweet one. But it seems incongruous with the mindset you paint in this article, don’t you think?

  • Anonymous

    it is a different mindset, for sure. lots of things have changed since i got engaged, though – that was a good five years ago, and i feel like a completely different person now in many ways. i think having a child gave me a much more deliberate mindset, one that’s much more inclined towards weighing options and making decisions based on logic in addition to emotion.

  • Anonymous

    this was so helpful – i think you’re right, there’s no way to avoid a little bit (or a lot) of buyer’s remorse in the wake of such a major decision.

  • Anonymous

    Why is Brooklyn out of the question? I have a garden apt with a yard, many of my friends with kids do too. Good schools, culture, and some suburban feel in many neighborhoods. I doubt upstate is much cheaper than Brooklyn anyway.

  • Anonymous

    we chose the area we did for many reasons, including my husband’s commute and the affordability of housing, since we want to buy.

  • Pingback: Guys? | Ramshackle Glam by Jordan Reid

  • http://alternativehousewife.com Janine @ Alternative Housewife

    I definitely feel this. I love the stability of having a child and a family,  but I also deeply miss that feeling that anything could happen at any given time. Even just driving off to the beach at 3am… Notsomuch an option when baby bedtime is at 8pm. I never got to live in a downtown apartment and I sometimes feel trapped in the suburbs. There is balance to be found though, I think. And you’re right, nothing is better for kids than their own yard and swingset!

  • http://twitter.com/caro Caroline McCarthy

    “I’d rather pay money for a smaller place and have access to seven museums via a subway and get my kids into that at a early age.”

    I have to agree with you.  I spent my first half of childhood living in Manhattan and spending every weekend at a museum.  My friends still think it’s hilarious that my mom taught me about sex and human anatomy from the Greek sculptures at the Met.  I spent outdoor playtime at city playgrounds learning to interact with kids from backgrounds very different from mine.  Then we moved to the suburbs, and I was no longer walking to school, because we suddenly could only drive everywhere — no more subway. My classmates hung out at the mall all weekend. Everyone was white.
    It’s a really tough call in my opinion. On one hand, there’s the slower pace, stability, and open space of small towns. On the other hand, thanks to SUVs and Wal-Mart, small towns just aren’t what they used to be. I’m years off from having kids, but I sometimes wonder if offering them access to that kind of urban diversity and cultural awareness is worth the premium.

  • http://twitter.com/caro Caroline McCarthy

    PS: In case I didn’t reiterate it before, Jordan, this was a wonderful and well-written post.

  • Jane

    Great post, Jordan. I can relate to the feeling of paralysis when you’re lucky enough to have a lot of options. Sounds like you and your husband made a good decision for your family.

  • KBNYC2

    I am so very impressed with your honesty and beautifully written intimacy throughout this post. I too grew up here in NYC and have often felt overwhelmed by the limitless amount of choice. I am jealous of your bravery to try life outside of this amazing circus. Best of luck!

  • Molly

    SUCH a touching post. Thank you for your honesty and for saying so many of the times I feel as well. Congrats on your beautiful family and this next stage of your life!

  • Steph Geliebter

    This is great. I love this post soo much. Hope everything works out for you and your family with the big move! :)