Quantcast

F This

Acting on the advice of…well, everyone, I decided to stop with this ridiculousness as of Saturday morning. Friday night I had a slight fever, chills and aches, and extreme fatigue…and I don’t think I have the flu; I think I’m not eating enough (insights like this are why they pay me the big bucks). I ate something light last night, because given how my body has responded to this cleanse, I think it’s important to at least make some effort to “ease” myself back into normal-eating mode. I’ve also been drinking the remaining lemonades and cashew juices as snacks today (Kendrick has been assisting), ‘cause they’re quite yummy.

I’ve repeatedly voiced my belief that cleanses are unhealthy and unnecessary, and this didn’t do a whole lot to change my mind. I’m not slamming BPC specifically; I actually think that as cleanses go this one isn’t as bad as some (I was much less hungry on BPC than I was when I tried the Master Cleanse). My specific issue with BPC is that it’s way too expensive, and I feel like the price ratchets the danger level up to Orange: the expense both makes clients feel like it’s a “magic juice” (jeez, for $60ish bucks a day it better be) and more determined to “go through with it,” even if their bodies are screaming for them not to. This is a test geared towards ambitious young people who have spent years honing their ability to get an A on an exam, get into the best school, make the most money…and now they’re applying all that drive to depriving their bodies of what they need.

The weirdest – and most dangerous, in my opinion – part of cleanses? Behind the fatigue, aches, and chills is a kind of high. It’s sort of exciting, being able to exert this kind of control over your body. And to me, that kind of excitement doesn’t feel all that distantly related to an eating disorder. Last night, when I was deciding whether or not to stop, I suddenly realized that I felt guilty. Depressed at my inability to “push through”. I wanted to show my body that I was the boss; that it couldn’t tell me what to do…and that feeling reminded me way too much of when I used to not eat enough a few years back. I’m not saying that people who do cleanses necessarily have eating disorders, but I do believe that the mindset that permits one to try a cleanse (and I’m including myself in this category) is one that’s perhaps more likely to exhibit signs of disordered eating. The simple truth: something about the hyper-regulation associated with this cleanse reminded me of how I felt when I was a young actress and was determined to be as slim as possible – whatever the price, whatever the consequences.

Now, I get that I’m probably not the best candidate for a cleanse (nowadays, I give zero thought to healthy eating on a daily basis), and I didn’t do this particularly by-the-book (hello, Chinese food and glass of wine)…but still, isn’t the whole concept behind this cleanse that it’s geared towards girls like me, who enjoy their burgers and red wine, but just need to “recharge” on occasion? Maybe it works well for someone who already has a fairly Spartan diet or is used to regulating what they eat, but to me this did not feel safe, and it did not feel healthy: it felt like a test of willpower rather than a step towards a “better” lifestyle. The point of a cleanse is to force your body into doing something that it does not want to do (screw the literature that says “this is your body returning to its natural state, blah blah blah”; nope, your body wants food). I think that we need to pay more attention to what our bodies want…certainly not less.

The main reason I stopped the cleanse wasn’t because I felt sick: I stopped because I was sitting there at my desk, typing listlessly away on my computer and wanting it to be nighttime already so I could go to sleep and be one day closer to being done with this whole thing…and then I realized that I was actually wishing the days to pass more quickly. And then I looked outside into a gorgeous summer evening and thought to myself, “How many nights like this are there in your life when you’re 28 years old and living in the greatest city in the world with someone you love?” The answer is, “Not many.” And I’m not going to waste a single one of them sitting on my couch, shivering, sweating, and sipping on kale juice.

Be healthy, but be happy, too.



You Might Also Like:


  • Ashley

    Oh Jordan, it makes me so happy to know that you're stopping! Go get some chicken soup, girl. :-)

  • jordanreid

    :)

  • annie

    Thanks SO much for posting this. I absolutely agree with you about the control issue that the cleanse seems to unearth. Like you, I tried to fit into an image that was truly unhealthy for me. I really appreciated your honesty and wish more people would stay away from the cleanses. I love food and love to enjoy what my body can do when I fuel it. I hope more people read this. Thanks again. :)

  • Adda

    Jordan, an acquaintance of mine did the master cleanse for an article on (the now defunct) Double X. Its a great piece and she largely came to a similar conclusion as you — which is that the most harmful part of the cleanse was the psychological imprint it left for her because of the high she felt restricting herself. Check it out: http://www.doublex.com/section/health-science/i…

  • katiegeha

    Finally! Someone making sense about these cleanse nonsense. This is a really important post. Thank you.

  • saphira

    Totally agree!! I think by doing these cleanses your body gets confused. So when you start eating again your body starts 'storing' the food just in case 'the cleanse' happens again. And that's why some people immediately gain weight after doing a cleanse.
    Just listen to your body and if you do feel like you need a cleanse there are lots of them out there where you are allowed to eat (like the vegetable cleanse. You just eat fruits and vegetables for a week…)

  • Clare

    Thanks for being so candid about your experience, your post is spot-on.

  • akbarnard

    I've done BPC 3 times. The first time, I loved it and hated it. I felt great exerting control, like you said and I definitely have food issues. I don't have an eating disorder, but I definitely have issues with food and body image. What I liked most was how much energy I had. Usually I fall asleep as soon as my Husband and I get in a car to drive anywhere, and I was awake and energized and drove us to NH on the 2nd day of the cleanse. I was also very, very excited to eat vegetables and fruit, just like they say which made me feel healthy and happy. The last night of the cleanse I was beating myself up for being hungry though. I'd read so many things about people not even feeling hungry during the cleanse that I felt like I'd failed. not good. Like I said in an earlier comment, the second one did not go well so I stopped after 2 days. The 3rd came when I was feeling overweight and unhappy with my eating habits and like I needed a kick in the butt to get back on track. I signed up for just 2 days because I had liked the results from my early stop last time. It went much more easily and I felt great after, however, I ran a race the 3rd day and got my worst time, even though they say you can do more and be faster.
    You're right- your body DOES need food and yes BPC gives you a lot of the nutrients, etc that you require, but it needs more than that. I didn't want to admit it at first, but it was the cleanse that caused the bad race.
    I think I will keep using BPC because I do like the results and as body dysmorphic as it is, I do like the control and feeling like I can wield some over my eating habits.
    Actually, just realized I did it a 4th time, to prepare for a weekend of a lot of eating- yeah- so instead of doing it to change my habits, I did it to lose the weight I'd gain that weekend. Hmmmm.
    Long story long- I agree with your assessment above, and I think that for people like me, who want a quick fix that is somewhat easy it does work and I admit that it is probably not the healthiest way to do it. And, I have been struggling the past few months with figuring out how to be healthy without having to spend $165 on a quick fix to do it.

  • http://petitebitcherie.tumblr.com Ginger

    Good for you! I could ramble for hours about how women our age have a completely twisted and unhealthy attitude to food – they're wasting their 20s cleansing, getting colonics and freaking out because OMG they had pizza or dessert. As you pointed out… if you allow yourself to become obsessed with dieting, you miss out on life. End of story.

  • raiiin

    i'm glad you listened to your body! honest posts like this one? probably the main reason why i appreciate your blog so much.

  • jenifercurran

    Love this. Thank you.

  • Angie

    Congrats Jordan, this really takes passive aggressiveness to a new level. Nice job!

  • Marin

    This is the sanest thing I've read in a long time.

  • http://snackreligious.blogspot.com Jennette

    Thanks for being honest. I get so annoyed by the “cleanse worshippers” I run into. I just have this sneaking suspicion most people don't really do it to “cleanse,” but to lose weight. And, as you point out, it wobbles dangerously over the line separating “diets” (which I don't like anyway) from “eating disorders.” Add the price of commercial cleanses, and I'm the opposite of sold.

    I'll be participating in a CSA (Community Supported Agriculture) program and eating lots of fruits and vegetables from June to November this year. I think I'll call that my “cleanse.”

  • Devon

    It does? How? This is the opposite of passive agressive actually. Your comment, on the other hand, is not.

  • Felicity

    Bravo. Great post, great effort, and I applaud your honesty in the face of free stuff!

  • MelissaMelissa

    I hope you feel better by now! I also really liked your insight about how this compares to your L.A. days.

  • http://indiscriminatemusings.tumblr.com/ M2TheQuinn

    I did the BPC in 2008, Foundation cleanse. I followed the entire prep and cleanse process as they recommended (down to colonic),and felt awful through the entire process. Shaky, unfocused, headaches… Friends have had amazing results, and I envy them, but I share in your strife.. Hope you feel better

  • Pingback: okay, okay – my weight loss tips! « follow my bliss

  • mzchristine

    Very glad you had decided to stop. The best cleanse out there is water, fruit and vegetables. There is no need to x out solids from our lives.

  • Pingback: (Happy) First Anniversary! «